Usually I wait a couple of days after finishing a book before writing my blog, so that I can mull over what I have read and see what my lasting impressions are. I turned the last page of the Karen Joy Fowler’s Booker longlisted novel ‘We are All Completely Beside Ourselves’ about 3 days ago. Now all I seem to be able to remember is that it has a bright yellow cover! There must be more, there must be more – this is a book whose main text is preceded by no fewer than 42 rave reviews, spread over 5 pages. There must be more to it than yellow!
Rosemary is at University and tells her story by moving between her current student life and flashbacks to her childhood. Raised in a highly academic family (her father was a professor and researcher), Rosemary is haunted by the sudden disappearance of both her siblings; Fern, a sister, vanished when Rosemary was 5 years old and their brother, Lowell, 6 years later. The emergence of the truth about where Fern went and what happened to her subsequently, together with the sudden re-appearance of Lowell, cause Rosemary’s past and present to collide.
The book tackles some highly emotive and also divisive moral issues, but the novel seemed to me to be unhelpful in persuading the reader to one view or another – in that sense, it lacked depth. It was also clumsy in the way the key scientific theories were explained e.g. by means of a lecture delivered by one of Rosemary’s professors or explanations of her father’s methods. My over-riding feeling was that the book couldn’t quite make up its mind what it was – too theoretical to be an imaginative tale, too lacking in plot to be a page-turning read.
I will be watching with interest to see how this work fares in the Booker Prize awards. Judging by the number of plaudits, its got to be a front-runner. As for me, unfortunately I am not Completely Beside Myself with excitement about it!